This paper shows that exposing children to illegal labor markets makes them more likely to be criminals as adults. I exploit the timing of a large anti-drug policy in Colombia that shifted cocaine production to locations in Peru that were well-suited to growing coca. In these areas, children harvest coca leaves and transport processed cocaine. Using variation across locations, years, and cohorts, combined with administrative data on the universe of individuals in prison in Peru, affected children are 30% more likely to be incarcerated for violent and drug-related crimes as adults. The biggest impacts on adult criminality are seen among children who experienced high coca prices in their early teens, the age when child labor responds the most. No effect is found for individuals that grow up working in places where the coca produced goes primarily to the legal sector, implying that it is the accumulation of human capital specific to the illegal industry that fosters criminal careers. I also rule out that effects are driven by other factors such as exposure to violence, income effects, or lower schooling. In line with the criminal capital channel, early exposure to illegal labor markets also has broader implications in terms of state legitimacy: as individuals involved in the illegal industry learn how to navigate outside the rule of law, they lose trust in government institutions as adults. However, consistent with a model of parental incentives for human capital investments in children, I find that the rollout of a conditional cash transfer program that encourages schooling mitigated the effects of exposure to illegal industries. Finally, I show how the program can be targeted by taking into account the geographic distribution of coca suitability and spatial spillovers. In sum, this paper takes a first step towards understanding how criminals are formed by unpacking the way in which crime-specific human capital is developed at the expense of formal human capital in “bad locations.”
Featured in Marginal Revolution
Long-term Effects of Temporary Labor Demand: Free Trade Zones, Female Education and Marriage Market Outcomes in the Dominican Republic
Bright Minds, Big Rent: Gentrification and the Rising Returns to Skill joint with Lena Edlund and Cecilia Machado. NBER Working Paper w21729, November 16, 2015. Featured in The Washington Post, The Atlantic, The Chicago Tribune, Bloomberg View, and The Huffington Post.
Inter-Generational Benefits of Improving Access to Justice for Women: Evidence from Peru joint with Guadalupe E. Kavanaugh and Iva Trako.
Exporting Criminal Capital: Spillover Effects of U.S. Deportations on Gang Expansion, Human Capital and Child Migration in El Salvador (draft available upon request)
The Effects of Indoor Prostitution on Sex Crime: Evidence from New York City joint with Riccardo Ciacci
What Makes a Good Public Servant? Criminal Exposure and Performance in Office joint with Jorge Mangonnet
Auspicious Birth Dates Among Chinese in California joint with Douglas Almond, Christine Pal Chee and Nan Zhong. Economics and Human Biology, July 2015.